Recently, Katsina state governor,
Aminu Bello Masari, constituted four committees to investigate activities of
four critical sectors under the administration of his predecessor, Barr.
Ibrahim Shehu Shema. In this piece, MUAZU ELAZEH examines issues surrounding
the probe.
Few days to the much talked about
one hundred days in office, the Katsina
state governor, Aminu Bello Masari turned his
full search light on the
activities of four critical sectors of the state during the immediate past administration of
the state as he inaugurated committees
to undertake holistic investigation of the
activities of the sectors from 2011 to 2015.
The four key sectors whose
activities will be scrutinised as per the
committee constituted are Katsina State Universal Basic Education Board
(SUBEB), Katsina State Road Maintenance Agency (KASROMA), MDGs/SURE-P, and, the Department of Girl
Child Education and Child Development.
The task to investigate the
activities of SUBEB lies in the hands of
eight persons comprising, Dr Kabi Matazu, the rector of Federal Polytechnic Kazaure and a seasoned academic
as chairman, Hamisu Danmusa, Abdullahi
Jika Ruma, Inusa Mohammed, Shehu Bello, Muhammad Dan’Ali, Habibu Dara, Kamilu Sheik Malumfashi
with Aminu Bello Bakori as secretary.
Indeed, another sector for which
a committee was set up to unravel the
activities of previous government is the department of Girl Child education and child development. This
committee has former commissioner and
frontline woman politician, Mariya Abdullahi as
chairperson while Zainab Kaita, Umar Gambarawa, Binta Abba,
Abubakar Masari, Tanimu Runka and
Nurruden Mannir are to serve as members with
Awwal Ibrahim Kankara acting as the committee scribe.
To investigate the activities of
the Katsina state Roads Maintenance Agency (KASROMA), eight persons including
its chairman, Engr Abdul Kanti, Amadu
Bello Charanchi, Shehu Tingilin, Lawal Usman Bagiwa, Bishir Babba Kaita and Abdulaziz Indala have
been named.
While activities of the
department of MDGs/SURE-P within the said
period will be investigated by the committee headed by Abdullahi Imam with Muntari Abdulkadir, Farouk Jobe,
Isa Ahmed, Almajir Salihu, Lawal Bosa
and Abu Rimi as members. One Mohammed Sani Katsina is to serve as secretary of the committee.
Essentially, the committees had
the same terms of reference which
included ascertaining the location and status of project executed between 2011 and 2015, to determine whether
or not funds earmarked for the said
projects have been judiciously allocated and economically used.
In the case of SUBEB, the
committee is tasked with the additional responsibility to ascertain the actual
Teacher-Pupil ratio and advise on how
critical primary education infrastructure could be improved.
Of course the committees’ term of
reference included determining whether
or not financial and administrative operational guidelines were adhered to in the conduct of the
organisational activities.
The four committees were
constituted on Monday the 17th of August and they have three weeks within which to submit their
reports.
While inaugurating the committee,
Governor Masari tasked them to do their
job without any fear or favour, insisting that the essence was to reposition
operations of government for greater efficiency and effectiveness in service delivery.
He stressed that the setting up
of the committee had nothing to do with
witch-hunt but was borne out of the desire to set records of government activities straight and admonished
the committee members to resist the
temptation of allowing their personal interest and preference interfere with the job.
Although the committee was coming
few days to the one hundred days in
office in the life of the Masari-led administration, analyst said
it was long coming because the governor at
different fora, had cause to lament the
alleged waste and more aptly, mismanagement of resources in some critical sectors of the state government
under the previous administration.
In one of his interactions with
newsmen, the governor observed that the
head of one of the agencies being investigated surpassed his statutory spending limits and acted without
recourse to either the board or the
supervising ministry.
Perhaps it may not be mere
coincidence that the four agencies being
investigated are among the sectors seen as being juicy.
For instance, SUBEB, the agency
saddled with the responsibility of
coordinating primary education, has according to available records, received huge amount of money within the
period to be covered by the
investigation, as counterpart funding to strengthen primary education.
But then, although the immediate
past government said it has achieved
remarkable success in repositioning primary education, a special committee constituted by the governor to asses
state of primary schools in the state,
declared that the situation of over 2000 primary school were deplorable.
Specifically, the committee
headed by its chairman, Dr Badamasi
Charanchi hinted that close to 14,000 primary school children across the state currently learn on
bare floor due to dearth of chairs,
seats and other infrastructure. Perhaps this
revelation by the committee may be one of the reasons that informed the governor’s decision to engage on a whole
scale investigation.
The KASROMA is one of the state
government agencies that have continued
to enjoy over eighty per cent budgetary releases during the period under review.
Although it was saddled with the
responsibility of maintaining the roads
across the state and other critical road infrastructure like street lights and the likes, the agency delved
its hands, surprisingly in economic
empowerment activities where it claimed to have taught some unemployed youths skills and provided
computers to them. This is even as there
is an agency statutorily responsible for handling this.
As for the department of Girl
Child education and child development,
its activities principal among which is the conditional cash
transfer (CCT) programme, had been
subjected to harsh criticism by people who
levelled allegations of bias on the authority.
The investigative committee will
no doubt investigate, among other
things, the way and manner in which this all important programme
which sought toprovide stipends to
school pupils as part of initiatives to
encourage enrolment, retention and completion of girl child in primary school, was handled.
Indeed, among the agencies and or
department to be investigated is the
MDGs/SURE-P both of which had attracted wide publicity in the state for different reasons, perhaps due to funding
reportedly pumped to both by the federal
government.
Our correspondent reports that
the news of the committee was received
with wild jubilation in some corners of the state with those applauding it insisting that it is a signal that
the incumbent government will not
plunder the state resources and will ensure value for money.
“The Governor is sending a signal
to all those who care to see because he
will be setting a benchmark within which he will be judged after living office. An administration that begins
with probe will no doubt be mindful of
its action knowing full well that probe awaits it at expiration” Saifullahi Danlami, a retired
Director in the state civil service
said.
As at the time of going to press,
it was reliably gathered that all the
committees had commenced work with what sources said was thorough scrutiny of the books of all the agencies
being investigated.
Views are being expressed that
the investigation, which according to
the committee members, promised to be thorough, is bound to unravel some can of worms as far as the way and
manner the state’s resources were
expended, was concerned.
Reaction Trails Probe Committees
But even before the constitution
of the committees, the heads of some
these agencies had appeared before the anti-graft agency, Economic
and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC)
for questioning.
As should be expected, the
constitution of the committee has continued
to engender different reactions from different sections of the
state with people expressing diverse
opinions as to the propriety or otherwise.
While some respondents believed
it was timely, necessary and the only
option left to recover the alleged looted funds, others see it as
mere distraction and deliberate attempt to
witch hunt officials of the immediate
past administration.
The opposition PDP which appears
to be at the receiving end of the
committee’s activities and indeed, most of the present government’s actions and inactions, described the
committee as a deliberate attempt to
witch hunt some persons and rubbish the good track records of achievement left behind by the immediate past
administration.
Speaking to LEADERSHIP, the
Katsina state PDP chairman, Salisu Yusuf
Majigiri condemned the constitution of the committee insisting that there was ulterior motive for it “since all
these agencies are being investigated by
the EFCC”.
“We condemn the constitution of
these committees in the strongest terms.
What is the essence of the EFCC that is investigating all these agencies? For one, all the members of the
committee are members of the APC and how
do you expect fairness?” “The probe is
political since the committee is made up mainly of card carrying APC members” Majigiri added
insisting that the whole exercise smack
of deliberate attempt to witch hunt officials of the immediate past administration.
But an APC youth Leader and
frontline member of the Masariyya Group-an
organisation propagating the political ideals of Governor Masari-, Mallam Yusuf Hamisu Tirmigis said the constitution
of the committee was not only necessary,
but timely considering the enormity of alleged
mismanagement of the state’s resources.
“Regardless of our political
leaning, we must accept the fact that
some looted or mismanaged funds have to be recovered. The present government is trying to ask questions on how
the resource of the state was handled so
as to ascertain whether or not there was value for money. Why are some people grumbling?”
Tirmigis queried. Abdurrahman Dutsinma is a member of the Katsina state chapter
of Coalition of Civil Societies. He said
employing the service of consultants who
are politically neutral was the best thing for the government to do.
“For a committee of this nature,
government ought to have hired services
of consultants who can do the job better. Because using people who belong to your party and are
against the previous government, there
is likely to be bias in their findings”.
“But then having said that, the
setting up of the committee is the best
thing governor Masari could have done because there are a lot of allegations of financial misappropriation
levelled against the previous
government”.
Dutsinma who is the chairman of
Katsina Budget Awareness Initiative
(KBAI) added that “It is good to investigate these sectors because
it reflects all the agencies where there
are widespread views that so many
resources were.
Credit: Leadership